Guide
Collect Google reviews without breaking the rules
In short
You collect Google reviews within the rules if you ask all guests the same way, do not filter by stars and give nothing in return. Google prohibits rewards and selectively asking only for positive reviews (“review gating”). Stempla asks for stars after the visit and shows every guest the same button to Google, without rewards.
Last updated:
Why do Google reviews matter for local businesses?
Many people check the reviews in Google Maps or Google Search before a first visit. For cafés, hairdressers or restaurants they are often the first impression.
Happy guests often do not think of writing a review. That is why it pays to ask actively. What matters is how you ask.
Reviews also help you. They show what guests value and where things go wrong. If you read them regularly, you spot recurring topics such as waiting times or friendliness early.
Which rules apply?
Google sets out the rules in its policies for contributions to Google Maps, in the section on fake engagement. Under them you may not reward reviews, whether with money, discounts, free products or stamps. You may also not selectively ask only happy guests for reviews or discourage negative ones.
The Austrian Unfair Competition Act (UWG) also sets limits. In its annex, the so-called blacklist, item 23b prohibits claiming that reviews come from real customers without taking reasonable steps to check this. Item 23c prohibits submitting or commissioning fake reviews and misrepresenting reviews to promote products.
Whether a specific practice breaks these rules depends on the individual case. This guide summarises the principles and is not legal advice. Read the current version of Google’s policy yourself and, if in doubt, ask an expert.
What is review gating?
With review gating, a business first asks internally how satisfied a guest is. Only happy guests are then sent to Google. Unhappy ones end up in an internal form.
That distorts the picture on Google. Google explicitly prohibits selectively asking only for positive reviews. Google can remove reviews that break its policies.
Asking about satisfaction is not a problem in itself. What matters is that every guest then sees the same path to Google, however satisfied they are.
How to ask for reviews the right way
The best moment is shortly after the visit, while the impression is fresh. Keep the request short and friendly. Anyone who does not want to review does not have to.
Critical reviews are part of it. A calm, factual reply shows new guests how you handle criticism.
You can also place the link to your Google page as a QR code at the till or print it on the receipt. All that matters is that every guest sees it the same way and nobody gets anything for it.
- Ask all guests, not just those who seem happy.
- Show everyone the same link or QR code to your Google page.
- Give nothing in return: no discount, no stamp, no prize draw.
- Do not let your team or family write reviews.
- Reply factually to reviews, including critical ones.
How Stempla handles it
After a visit, the Stempla app sometimes briefly asks the guest for 1 to 5 stars and, if they like, a text for your team. It goes to you and is not public. You only see the name if the guest shares it.
If you enter your Google review link in the business profile or for a location, the app shows every guest the same “Also review on Google” button. However many stars someone gives, the button looks the same. Stempla does not filter and gives no stamps for it.
Guests are asked only from their second visit day and at most once a week. They can turn the question off in their profile. You see how many guests opened Google afterwards, but not whether they left a review there.
For 1 or 2 stars with text you get a push notification, without the guest’s text and not between 9 pm and 8 am. That lets you react quickly. Owners and managers see feedback; staff do not.
What to avoid
Do not buy reviews or have them written. Do not ask friends, family or staff to review your business either.
Do not reward reviews, not even through a prize draw or an extra stamp. Do not send only happy guests to Google. And do not pressure guests who want to write a critical review.
Do not flag genuine reviews just because they are critical. Flagging on Google is meant for reviews that break the policies, for example because they are offensive or do not come from real guests.
Frequently asked questions
Can I ask guests for a Google review?
Yes. What matters is that you ask all guests the same way, not just happy ones, and give nothing in return. That way the request follows the principles of Google’s policy.
Can I give a discount or stamp for a Google review?
No. Google prohibits rewards for reviews, including discounts, free products or stamps. Stempla therefore gives no stamps for reviews.
What is review gating?
Review gating means only happy guests are sent to Google while unhappy ones end up in an internal form. Google prohibits selectively asking only for positive reviews.
Is feedback in Stempla public?
No. Stars and text only go to the business, where owners and managers see them. The business only sees the name if the guest shares it.
Can the business see whether a guest reviewed it on Google?
No. The business only sees whether Google was opened after a piece of feedback. Neither Stempla nor the business learns whether the guest actually reviewed there.
How often does Stempla ask guests for feedback?
At most once a week and only from the second visit day at a business. Guests can turn the question off in their profile under “Ask for feedback after visits”.
Written by Raphael Bogner, who builds and runs Stempla (MaYE Media, Aspach, Austria).
Read more
Ready for a digital stamp card?
3-month free trial, all features, no commitment.